Sunday, April 27, 2008

Ashes to Ashes - Karma Kamelions

The Happy Day

"It's like a powder keg around here. Just waiting for a spark. But it's not going to happen, not this week, not on my patch, not for Di. Chris, get up there and kick the door down."
"Hang on. Why risk a spark? Look and learn, fictional constructs!"
"Right... let her do her stuff for a minute and THEN kick the sodding door down."

How the hell do I review this episode beyond, quite simply, "much better"?

The writers have clearly had a decent night's sleep and downed a bottle of Chris Chibnall patented talent retcon before working on this. The characters have been slightly modified to be less pointless and annoying. Raymondo, for example, while still pig ignorant and offensive, is shown to be a hard working copper who, while not able to work out the answers, can at least ask the right questions. Chris is not the complete arse of last week, but instead shows himself to be a kind of social Kamelion. I dare say few saw that brilliant Aunty Jack skit where the waiter at a club changes personality and manners to become equal to every person he serves, (butch beer drinker, camp martini know-it-all, shy soft drink collector)? Here we see Chris changes similarly in company - he's vulgar and coarse with Ray, exhuberant and open-minded with Shazza, a vaguely competent cop with no personality to Alex, and... well... Chris when he's with Gene. Gene too has lost the 'talk tough' of last week and IS the hard bastard we remember, quite willing to strap an innocent man naked to a pool table and then play a game if it will prevent loss of life.

The loss of life in this case is the London Liberation Front, a mysterious terrorist organization disguided with "Thatcherite economics" and in particular the upcoming marriage betwixt Charles and Di. Gene tells his superiors he will stop this outfit and their plans and makes sure his whole department is on the same page. Well, except for Alex of course, who walks the knife's edge this week between pure comedy character and someone Sparacus would aspire to.

One of the truly heartwarming parts of Life on Mars, was the fact that Sam's compassion drove the storylines. True, he might be lying in bed and this is all a dream, but he can't take that chance, and so helps people whenever he can. Alex, however, thinks this is all a dream and refuses to become involved. She openly tells everyone she's dreaming all this, and they clearly hear what she's saying. Gene, Ray and Chris have wordlessly decided to avoid discussing this, but the rest of the world do not know Sam Tyler and think she's a nutter.

Worse, an incredibly condescending and patronizing nutter. For all her bollocks about being brilliant at personality profiling, she is unable (or more likely unwilling) to talk in a manner anyone understands, and sounds like she ate a psych text book that keeps repeating on her. Worse, she goes out of her way to be annoying in a way unseen outside of Ben Chatham. Imagine him trying to console someone, crank up the cynacism and you have Alex Drake.

In short, Gene spends a good chunk of this episode apologizing for HER behaviour. And considering he at one point decks a suspect and drags them down four flights of steps after they dare call him a coward, its damning that he still seems the more responsible and sympathetic of the two.

To my intense relief, the story makes it clear that Alex's detachment to Gene's World is not endearing and cheerfully smacks the bint down as Alex bumps into her own mother - who in 1981 was a successful female lawyer single-handedly trying to bring down the Metropoliton Police Force. But just in case we start to feel for Alex's mum - who died in 1981 in a car bombing - we get to find out that not only is she blinked by an unreasonable hatred of the police, she is a careless and neglectful mother with a chip on her shoulder. For such an intelligent woman, it takes a REMARKABLY long time to notice the police woman she's tearing chunks out shares the name of her daughter and even calls her "mum". Pretty much all my feelings on Alex Drake senior are summed up by the following phrase I hurled at the screen after she stormed out of a pub screaming feminist propaganda:

"OI! PAY FOR YOUR OWN FUCKING DRINKS, YOU BITCH!"

This episode is more like Life on Mars as it gleefully skips from comedy to some quite dark places indeed. Gene is brilliant at both, of course, from the side-splitting treatment of some cardboard boxes, his incredibly backhanded compliment to Shazza when she points out the freaking obvious he overlooked, to his passionate belief in office moral and police tradition. There is also amongst other stuff him being serious, such as having to provide police protection to a man he wants dead, having to arrest a man whose cause Gene personally believes in, and the scene where he insists that the police have the rare ability to change things and are duty bound to do to make life better for the people they serve.

There's also a brilliant sequence where Alex visits a New Romantics disco and meets Boy George as Fade to Grey plays in the background (that's the music video for State of Decay if you check out the BBC site), only to discover Shazza and Chris are some of the... er... New Romantics. Then of course, there is Pointless Clown Cameo where she chases him into the toilets and nearly throttles some poor girl whose only crime was to go to the loo dressed a bit like a clown. And said girl is more frightening than the Clown anyway. PCC also leads to plenty of other 'twisted flashback' sequences which just go to emphasize how much better Sam was at coping with Gene's world.

The plot also has a dark root in it that leads to a shockingly dark finale as a drunken remark from Alex concerning the future leads to, well, bad shit happening. But, like when Alex puts on her tart outfit (which she seems to be contractually obliged to do at least once an episode) to get laid, she insists on taking no responsibility for her actions as this is all a dream. But how many times is Gene going to accept this philosophy? We're heading for showdown, and the complete lack of URST between Alex and Gene gives me hope the result will be worth it.

Luigi is still a waste of space though.

Next Week - Trixie la Bouche from Red Dwarf claims she's been raped. The police aren't interested. Alex is. Everyone goes to a fancy dress ball. Alex dresses up as a prostitute. Again.

Um... not a lot to say except it better stay as good as this.

12 comments:

Jared "No Nickname" Hansen said...

Chris is not the complete arse of last week, but instead shows himself to be a kind of social Kamelion...Here we see Chris changes similarly in company - he's vulgar and coarse with Ray, exhuberant and open-minded with Shazza, a vaguely competent cop with no personality to Alex, and... well... Chris when he's with Gene.

I actually noticed that in the first episode when I watched it yesterday. He's nice to Shazza, but he behaves like an arsehole when Ray's around to fit in.

I find it a little disappointing, though, because I'd have thought it would be cool for Chris to have grown into a bit more of a Sam Tyler SNAG-style personality. Well, for the whole time. You know, like, Sam would have given him the confidence to be his own person and not fit in with the crowd.

I guess that's why I would also have liked Ray not to be in it - have Chris being the next tier up on the ladder. But I can accept it.
BTW, ain't it odd how Chris is the only one who looks/seems even slightly older?

She openly tells everyone she's dreaming all this, and they clearly hear what she's saying. Gene, Ray and Chris have wordlessly decided to avoid discussing this, but the rest of the world do not know Sam Tyler and think she's a nutter.

Yes, it's actually quite annoying, eh?

she is unable (or more likely unwilling) to talk in a manner anyone understands, and sounds like she ate a psych text book that keeps repeating on her.

I KNOW! Isn't an important aspect of psychology knowing how to talk to people? It's like she's an outlet for the writers to show they've done their research. Even when talking to Arthur "DON'T LOOK AT ME!" Layton, who had a gun before going into the fantasy world she was talking that way...

For such an intelligent woman, it takes a REMARKABLY long time to notice the police woman she's tearing chunks out shares the name of her daughter and even calls her "mum".

...*sigh* another one of those, eh?

But, like when Alex puts on her tart outfit (which she seems to be contractually obliged to do at least once an episode) to get laid, she insists on taking no responsibility for her actions as this is all a dream.

Ooh, maybe she'll get impregnated?

... well SOMETHING has to happen for her to accept she needs to take things seriously.

Oh, and something I felt the need to ask - what gave you the impression that Shazza is a lesbian? Because I saw the first ep yesterday, and I have to say I got the vibe she and Chris had crushes on one another. The only thing lesbian-y seemed to be her hair...

Youth of Australia said...

I actually noticed that in the first episode when I watched it yesterday. He's nice to Shazza, but he behaves like an arsehole when Ray's around to fit in.
I suppose so. Mind you, he's a lot more stupid in the first episode.

I find it a little disappointing, though, because I'd have thought it would be cool for Chris to have grown into a bit more of a Sam Tyler SNAG-style personality. Well, for the whole time. You know, like, Sam would have given him the confidence to be his own person and not fit in with the crowd.
Well, I was disappointed when Chris get caught between Shazza and Ray and unable to decide whether to say whether his trip to the disco was an enjoyable evening of New Romantics or a heterosexual's nightmare of attempted gang rape.

Jesus, Chris, out of all the people on the PLANET I thought you could stand up to Ray.

BTW, ain't it odd how Chris is the only one who looks/seems even slightly older?
I was amazed by that too. Gene and Ray have just changed their clothes, but Chris seems a decade older than the fresh-faced bloke we first met.

Yes, it's actually quite annoying, eh?
Luckily, the episode plays it for laughs.

I KNOW! Isn't an important aspect of psychology knowing how to talk to people? It's like she's an outlet for the writers to show they've done their research. Even when talking to Arthur "DON'T LOOK AT ME!" Layton, who had a gun before going into the fantasy world she was talking that way...
Well said. It's all right when she's asking Ray something like "who's the dominant personality" because he stands a chance of understanding the question (though what is so difficult about asking 'who acts like they're in charge?' I dunno), but she takes it to extremes.

...*sigh* another one of those, eh?
In fairness, the mum is considered a self-absorbed bitch far less intelligent than she likes to appear.

Ooh, maybe she'll get impregnated?
... well SOMETHING has to happen for her to accept she needs to take things seriously.

I think (THINK!) this ep might have managed it. But it could go either way.

Oh, and something I felt the need to ask - what gave you the impression that Shazza is a lesbian?
Well, when Alex first meets Shazza, Chris is there and makes a strange sort of pose where he is poking his own cheek and says, "I know what you're thinking: is she, or isn't she?"

I had no fucking idea what he was on about, but my dad says its a pop culture reference implying Shazza might be gay.

In this episode she seems as excited as the lads to see Alex's arse and admits to having plenty of friends who are gay.

Because I saw the first ep yesterday, and I have to say I got the vibe she and Chris had crushes on one another. The only thing lesbian-y seemed to be her hair...
Well, she WAS doing her hair during that bit. Maybe that's what Chris was referring to.

Mind you, Ray doesn't seem fussed at lesbians working in the police force. Or excited, come to that. As long he guesses right.

Jared "No Nickname" Hansen said...

Jesus, Chris, out of all the people on the PLANET I thought you could stand up to Ray.

Yeah. I wouldn't have thought Ray would find it too easy to make new friends in the Met, you know..

Well, when Alex first meets Shazza, Chris is there and makes a strange sort of pose where he is poking his own cheek and says, "I know what you're thinking: is she, or isn't she?"

Oh right. I forgot about that bit.

In this episode she seems as excited as the lads to see Alex's arse

Well, she's only human...

Mind you, Ray doesn't seem fussed at lesbians working in the police force. Or excited, come to that. As long he guesses right.


Bah. Ray. Nelson should have gotten his job..

Youth of Australia said...

Yeah. I wouldn't have thought Ray would find it too easy to make new friends in the Met, you know..
Since Ray and Chris followed Gene to the Met, I was hoping the dynamic might change, like Chris being the popular one and Ray the one with no friends...

Oh right. I forgot about that bit.
Fair enough.

Well, she's only human...
She also strokes Alex's hands at a few points, but that might mean nothing.

Bah. Ray. Nelson should have gotten his job
Nelson should have been in it SOMEWHERE! Luigi can't cut it. He's as miserable and self-pitying as Niel on a bad day.

Jared "No Nickname" Hansen said...

Since Ray and Chris followed Gene to the Met, I was hoping the dynamic might change, like Chris being the popular one and Ray the one with no friends...

..that would have been AWESOME!

I was thinking while I was watching the first ep that it's a bad sign when your mental improv fanwank is more interesting than the episode: at first I thought Layton was Lee Ingleby, so mentally I was thinking "OMG! Vic Tyler! Cross-over of the century!"

But then I saw it wasn't him. But something he said (God knows what it was) got me thinking - wait a minute, maybe this guy is another guy in a coma. From the year 2033!

..and that wasn't true either. He was just a guy with a gun.

Nelson should have been in it SOMEWHERE! Luigi can't cut it. He's as miserable and self-pitying as Niel on a bad day.

I have to say he didn't leave much of an impression on me. And it was the pilot. Where we're meant to be shown the roles of the character. We see him speak a couple of lines of instantly forgettable dialogue and be pissed off by other people having fun. Why do they even go to an Italian restaurant to get pissed, anyway? Is that some sort of 80s thing?

Youth of Australia said...

..that would have been AWESOME!
It would have been interesting, at any rate.

"OMG! Vic Tyler! Cross-over of the century!"
Vic Tyler? Who? That's not Sam's dad, is it?

But then I saw it wasn't him. But something he said (God knows what it was) got me thinking - wait a minute, maybe this guy is another guy in a coma. From the year 2033!
Now THAT would have been good. LOM set today with a guy from the future. Very nice.

..and that wasn't true either. He was just a guy with a gun.
And a very strange nose.

I have to say he didn't leave much of an impression on me. And it was the pilot. Where we're meant to be shown the roles of the character. We see him speak a couple of lines of instantly forgettable dialogue and be pissed off by other people having fun. Why do they even go to an Italian restaurant to get pissed, anyway? Is that some sort of 80s thing?
Not 100% sure, but Alex lives in the room upstairs. As does the Clown of Evil.

Jared "No Nickname" Hansen said...

Vic Tyler? Who? That's not Sam's dad, is it?

Yeah, Sam's dad. I thought that would be a neat link.

Now THAT would have been good. LOM set today with a guy from the future. Very nice.

Yeah. I thought that could have accounted for his craziness in a cool way..

Not 100% sure, but Alex lives in the room upstairs.

Ah, yeah. There was a snippet of dialogue to suggest that at some point or another..

As does the Clown of Evil.

Do they have an awkward moment where they get out of their rooms at the same time the next morning?

"Oh. Hi"
"Ah. Yeah, hi."
...
"Yeah, that thing at the warehouse I just..."
"You just what?"
"...I thought you looked like you wanted to play rugby, you know. So...I thought I'd tackle you or... I don't know I can't explain it."
...
"Well see ya. Or not. It's not like I'm stalking you. Aw, crap.."

Youth of Australia said...

Yeah, Sam's dad. I thought that would be a neat link.
I thought that Vic Tyler was from Queer as Folk - isn't Sam's Dad VINCE Tyler and played by Lee Williams?

Ah, yeah. There was a snippet of dialogue to suggest that at some point or another..
Gene tells them to keep the noise down. I admit, at first I was confused how he managed to get Alex to her place and back to the pub when he could barely walk...

Do they have an awkward moment where they get out of their rooms at the same time the next morning?
No, cause that would be an interesting development.

"Oh. Hi"
"Ah. Yeah, hi."
...
"Yeah, that thing at the warehouse I just..."
"You just what?"
"...I thought you looked like you wanted to play rugby, you know. So...I thought I'd tackle you or... I don't know I can't explain it."
...
"Well see ya. Or not. It's not like I'm stalking you. Aw, crap.."

Scenes that should be included.

Jared "No Nickname" Hansen said...

I thought that Vic Tyler was from Queer as Folk - isn't Sam's Dad VINCE Tyler and played by Lee Williams?

Ah, I do like the chance to prove myself right with a link. BWAHAHAHA!

Youth of Australia said...

...so who was VINCE Tyler? Was HE in QAF? My head hurts... still, I finally finished "The Cyb Fest". Two more and the first century is finished! To quote LBC, "BWAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHA, I just killed a Reaper!"

Jared "No Nickname" Hansen said...

The Cyb Fest? Finished? Mein Gott!

"BWAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHA, I just killed a Reaper!"

Lol. I think that's the only truly funny thing that he's written.. I love that quote. I need to work it into something...

Youth of Australia said...

I admit I found that amusing. One line out of all that dross. Maybe you could do

Bloke in Car: Hey, poofter, nice Reaper skull!

...maybe not.